PrintMusic? hmm…

This blog has moved to the new domain You can find this article at


15 thoughts on “PrintMusic? hmm…

  1. Jay Anderson

    Sometimes with string scordatura the notated and sounding pitch are not the same. So in the example a guitarist seeing the E will pluck the differently tuned E string sounding a D. I believe this is common practice for harpists at least. (For other strings I believe the sounding pitch is usually notated.) My point being that the written low E was most likely intentional.

    The other mistakes I see in the finale version:
    – The grace slur in the second measure.
    – Measure 7 is missing a sixteenth note. I’m thinking beat 3 should be more like beat 3 in measures 4 and 8.
    – The slur somewhat obscures ledgers lines in measure 7. This may just be the low resolution rendering causing the problem. I’m not sure how much better lilypond fares here. Lilypond’s weightier ledger lines probably help.

  2. Janek Warchoł Post author

    Indeed, this may be scordatura – I’ve edited the post. However, I don’t think that using scordatura without explicitely mentioning it would be a good notation practice. After all, some guitar music with alternate tunings is notated without scordatura (I have a few drop D pieces with explicitely written pitch), so there is room for confusion if you don’t state things clearly – does Elaine Gould say something about this?
    As for grace notes’ slur, I think that it should go above the notes in this case. Unfortunately, LilyPond doesn’t do this by default as well.

  3. Helge

    @Jay: Harp notes are notated as they sound. When a harpist wants to play a C-sharp she kicks the C pedal down and plugs the C string. As long as she plays C-sharp all is fine. The next C or C-flat requires a kick up of the pedal. Sometimes she uses enharmonic changes.

  4. Andreas

    Why are you complaining just about the first measure? Measures #5,6, and 7 tell you to play the 108th fret. What a great guitar with so many frets!

  5. Quarko

    In newer music it is common that you give two staffs for one instrument in this case. One written as it sounds and one written for the hand/muscles.
    And both on the same sheet of paper. The reason is that musicians switch between the two. In slower parts they like to use the “written as it sounds” staff and when it becomes mechanical they like to switch to the other part.
    From my experience and from that of several of university composing-teachers there is no middle-way.

    1. Janek Warchoł

      Unfortunately WordPress does something really strange to the code when i paste it into a comment (some parts are just deleted) 😦
      But as for fingering positions, you have to use these overrides in the upper voice:

      \set TabVoice.minimumFret = #7
      \set TabVoice.restrainOpenStrings = ##t

      1. Richard Shann

        Thanks – I’ve been studying your clef stuff there too – I guess because guitarist’s don’t expect to be told they are notating in the wrong octave 🙂

        1. Janek Warchoł

          Looks nice, but don’t forget about setting string tuning to drop d for correct midi pitches.

          1. Richard Shann

            Thanks – yes, there is some other stuff about staff spacing which I can raid this for – I guess that you specially put that in to improve (or match) the appearance (rather than just getting it by the sort of lazy cut-and-paste I resort to).

    1. Janek Warchoł

      I’ve tried it (among some other options) but it didn’t quite work – for example, the indentation was eaten. I’ve sent you an invitation, maybe you could try yourself with more luck than me? 😉


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s